≡ Menu

Long Read of the Week: The Weirdest Year

[ A Speech by Marl Steyn at GatestoneA Hinge Moment of History e]

It was certainly the weirdest year. It began with a supremely weird decision by the entire world, except China and Sweden, to tank the global economy.

No one has ever done that before. The only major economic power to grow last year was China whose GDP is up by, I think, about 2.5 percent compared to declines everywhere else, including some actually catastrophic ones, such as 11% in the UK.

This decision to tank the entire global economy is something that strengthened China, the creator of the virus, and the exporter of the virus, and weakened any opposition to China — and that is how they began.

This first year of the new weirdness ended with the United States government pretending that its principal threat is a domestic terrorism movement that does not exist.

This is the characterization of the so‑called insurrection on January 6th. We were told two weeks later that there were going to be mass insurrections, not only in Washington but in every state capital. Montpelier, Vermont, for example, the smallest state capital in the Union, went into lockdown. There was no such insurrection at any of these state capitals.

Then they said, “No, there is going to be an insurrection on March 4th,” because that was Benjamin Harrison’s Inauguration Day back in the old days and people apparently attach such great significance to that, that there was going to be a mass insurrection. There was no such thing on March 4th. Now, we are told it will be March 20th.

I have lived in countries that have real domestic terrorism movements. It is not something that one should concoct out of whole cloth lightly. No country blessed enough not to have a domestic terrorism movement should be inventing one.

We used to be told back after 9/11, there was a cliché after 9/11, “If we don’t maintain our normal life, if we don’t carry on shopping, if we don’t carry on going to sports features, then the terrorists will have won!”

Now, it is the complete opposite with this new alleged domestic terrorism movement, and everything we do has to be changed. We have to have a permanently armed capital city in Washington. Because of this so‑called domestic terrorism movement, we have to have a border wall around the US Capitol. We are living in a blizzard of lies.

Perhaps that is the most disturbing feature of the last year: because most of us see far fewer people and go far fewer places than we did a year ago, we are more dependent on acquainting ourselves with reality through the computer, which means that we are more dependent on a handful of woke billionaires to tell us what reality is.

They are far more open than ever that they get to determine what are the agreed facts. Google made an explicit announcement about this recently. They said that sometimes they would put warnings on things that are factually accurate because, even though they are true, they do not think it is in society’s interest for people to be seeing it.

When you talk about freedom of expression, for most people, that is an abstract concept that does not have much practical bearing on their lives.

People do not think of it as a first‑order issue for their own lives because, unless you happen to have accidentally insulted a fire‑breathing imam who is determined to get his revenge or a particularly robust transgender activist who takes action against you, these are not issues that affect most people.

The big change over the last year is that these issues are no longer abstractions. Everyone in the Western world has had some familiarity with the core meaning of Western liberties, whether you are talking about freedom of speech, freedom of movement, freedom of association, freedom of religion, they have all become very real, even for people living the most quiet and uncontroversial lives. We have states, a few weeks ago issuing orders on who you were allowed to spend Christmas or July 4th with.

The ability to go to your church, the ability to open your hairdressing salon, the ability to go and get a cheeseburger at your local diner, all these abstract intellectual philosophical issues are now absolutely real for most people around the Western world. Yet, there has been very little pushback against it.

Even in America, I’ve always loved that American word ornery, which doesn’t really exist in Britannic English because Canadians aren’t ornery and New Zealanders aren’t ornery. Americans are ornery. I was a little surprised at the way — including the best-known American states on the planet, New York and California — basically accepted what was happening with this new regime.

There was a famous remark, I like to quote, by Lord Moulton, an English judge. He also had, during the World War I, what may be my all‑time favorite job title. He was director general of the explosives department — an enviable job title.

Lord Moulton said that what matters in any healthy society are not the small number of things that one is obliged to do, or, at the other end of the spectrum, the small number of things that one is not permitted to do, but the big chunk in the middle. It is not a question of whether you have to do it, or you are forbidden to do it, but whether we decide for ourselves about those aspects of our lives through what he called the realm of manners. By his estimation, about 80 percent of life should be within the realm of manners rather than within the realm of law.

Now everything is law: How far you have to stand away from people. The realm of manners, in Lord Moulton’s phrase — choice — has shrunk to nothing.

Everything now, is regulated by the state from above. We are now seeing, for example, influential voices. “The Guardian” newspaper in the UK for example, said the other day that whatever happens to the pandemic, and the COVID, and all the rest of us, they would like us to go into lockdown once every two years. It would supposedly be good for climate change. You do not see this in America, but you quite a lot on overseas news reports. BBC, in the early days of the pandemic, was doing all these encouraging reports on how Ireland where it is illegal for you to go more than three miles from your home….

RTWT@ [ A Speech by Marl Steyn at GatestoneA Hinge Moment of History e]

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • James ONeil September 22, 2021, 9:01 AM

    “Everything now, is regulated by the state from above. ”

    Perhaps we need a domestic terrorism movement, such as the one we had in 1776.

    • Mike Austin September 22, 2021, 10:04 AM

      We already have a domestic terrorism movement. It’s called the US Government.

      • ghostsniper September 22, 2021, 11:18 AM

        We need a counter-domestic terrorism movement named We the people.

  • Joe Krill September 22, 2021, 9:03 AM

    “Everyone in the Western world has had some familiarity with the core meaning of Western liberties, whether you are talking about freedom of speech, freedom of movement, freedom of association, freedom of religion, they have all become very real, even for people living the most quiet and uncontroversial lives.” We cannot forget that Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness all come from God. Add to this that we have freewill. Our forefathers were able to control their freewill and give us the United States of America. The greatest nation to ever exist and founded on the core values of Christianity.

  • Dirk September 22, 2021, 9:26 AM

    Fuck China
    Fuck bottled water.
    These pukes walking around all tatted up, are fucking losers of the first order. Being pimped,,,, look at me!
    Fuck our looser govt.
    Fuck corporate TV
    Fuck the system
    Fuck liberal left losers.
    Fuck Biden
    Fuck anybody elected
    Fuck the rules
    Fuck, well just fuck!

    Never in my life have I witnessed the lack of individuality like these times. I know we lost based on everybody allowing media,,,TV,,,,,radio,,,,,to dictate who’s cool, what’s cool, what to drive, and where to drive it. What cloths worn, and shoes picked. Being a dyed in the wool Crocs wearing fella year round.

    I instinctively move a different direction once I recognize a fad, a style. I will do it my way! Period.

    My fav was these fucking troglodytes from the cities wearing their lumber Jack outfit, with their lil beannys on the very back of their heads, and suspenders. God give me strength.

    The neck tattoos, what losers. Nothing screams looser more then a young man or woman “ players”. Some young once stunning women whom drank the koolaid destroyed themselves in keeping up,with the beautiful people.

    I sometime wonder if those people will ever wake up, then I remind myself, I could give a flying fuck.

    Just leave me alone, I’ll be fine in an hour or two.


    [Instant T-shirt:]

    • Mike Austin September 22, 2021, 11:06 AM

      Understood completely. Have a drink. I’m having one.

  • EX-Californian Pete September 22, 2021, 10:56 AM

    I guess my (really RED) state must be pretty “behind the times” on a whole bunch of that “restrictions of liberties” stuff. Not much “masking” going on at all, it’s still “cash & carry” for a firearm at the local gun shows, auctions, and yard sales. Brainless Biden’s inflation rates seem to be lower here than other states. Yeah, $2.82 for a gallon of gas sucks, but it’s a lot worse elsewhere.

    It’s a little hard for me to feel “restricted” after this morning’s events- what I thought was a pesky telemarketer call at 6:40 this morning turned out to be the NFA FFL 2 counties over with the news that my long-awaited Browning can be picked up on the 11th of next month- on Columbus Day.

    The driller I hired informed me a bit before noon that my cistern is actually spring-fed- no drilling needed, and has a static (natural) delivery pressure of about 2-ish PSI. So now all I need is a decent pitcher pump, and about 10′ of pipe. Then I’ll have an endless back-up water supply (once the water samples are tested & cleared), and maybe a filtration system if needed.
    No permits required, and I expect the overall costs to be under $800.

    As per the above cartoon, paying $2 a bottle for something that falls from the sky and gurgles up from the earth– for FREE? I’ll pass.

    And the Commiefornia Mega Drought gets worse- https://www.newsbreak.com/news/2379660237409/californians-falling-far-short-on-water-conservation-as-drought-worsens

    BUT, there’s “potable water fill-up” stations popping up for those with dry wells.
    However, they’re recommending that folks DON’T DRINK IT.
    Um, doesn’t the term “potable” mean “safe to drink?”

    Lastly, our own “Buckeye Bob” Gibbs is planning impeachment proceedings for Biden! https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/bob-gibbs-impechment-articles-biden

    God bless Ohio.

  • Mike Austin September 22, 2021, 10:59 AM

    Mr. Steyn goes on and on about China. He seems genuinely afraid of her—for good reasons perhaps. But scarcely a word about the monumental and insolvable problems China has. China is a gigantic, monstrous parasite with tentacles around the globe. She bribes, she steals, she lies, she kills—yet she creates nothing. She is expert at murdering 100,000,000 of her own citizens; she is a master at smashing female infants to death in the streets; she is well practiced in the art of enslaving one billion persons. She is a perverse negation of everything comprising Western Civilization.

    And what to do about all of this? Steyn has ideas—and they are good ones, even necessary ones—but they have no possibility of being carried out. None whatsoever. The problems delineated by Steyn resemble Alexander’s Gordian Knot.

    My own ideas? I have none. Except…Kindly remind panda-faced Xi Jinping that his Three Gorges Dam would, if it failed, cover one-third of China with water. It would be a shame if something happened to it. A real shame.

    And there you have it. The Gordian Knot has just been cut.

  • Teresa Pittman September 22, 2021, 12:51 PM

    Gee the folks that are restricting what we can view aren’t reporting on any pushback. Guess that means there isn’t any.

    • Boat Guy September 22, 2021, 9:31 PM

      Speaking of viewing, I just watched “Seven Days in May”; prescient and quaint at the same time. General James Scott at least put the USA first, General Mark Milley, not at all

  • Sirk September 22, 2021, 9:53 PM

    Mike you ever find your way to Klamath falls Oregon you got family, we’ll leave the lights on. Hell your all welcome here at me casa.

    LOVE the Tee!


    • Mike Austin September 23, 2021, 1:43 PM

      Dirk: Excellent! And by the way, I lived in Portland for 30 years. And oh! The tales I could weave!

      I have no vehicle—bereft of one now going on eight years—but ride one of my two ferociously expensive bicycles everywhere. I’ve ridden from Oklahoma to Colorado to New Mexico to Texas to Mississippi to Arkansas—and camped out most of the way. Next year I plan to leave around April and ride to Idaho, Oregon, Nevada and make my way home.

      See you in May. I’ll be thirsty.